Below are point totals for the balloting for the 2023 Rookie of the Year Award, as voted on by members of the Baseball Writers' Association of America. Ballots for each award were submitted before the start of the postseason from two writers in every city, based on the league covered.

The system rewards five points for first place, three for second place and one for third place.

AMERICAN LEAGUE RESULTS

Gunnar Henderson, BAL: 30 first-place votes, unanimous -- 150 points
Tanner Bibee, CLE: 20 (2nd-place votes), 7 (3rd) -- 67 points
Triston Casas, BOS: 6 (2nd), 7 (3rd) -- 25 points
Josh Jung, TEX: 3 (2nd), 7 (3rd) -- 16 points
Yainer Diaz, HOU: 1 (2nd), 3 (3rd) -- 6 points
Masataka Yoshida, BOS: 3 (3rd) -- 3 points
Edouard Julien, MIN: 2 (3rd) -- 2 points
Anthony Volpe, NYY: 1 (3rd) -- 1 point

NATIONAL LEAGUE RESULTS

Corbin Carroll, AZ: 30 first-place votes, unanimous -- 150 points 
Kodai Senga, NYM: 22 (2nd-place votes), 5 (3rd) -- 71 points
James Outman, LAD: 5 (2nd), 5 (3rd) -- 20 points
Nolan Jones, COL: 2 (2nd), 11 (3rd) -- 17 points
Matt McLain, CIN: 1 (2nd), 2 (3rd) -- 5 points
Spencer Steer, CIN: 4 (3rd) -- 4 points
Eury Pérez, MIA: 1 (3rd) -- 1 point
Elly De La Cruz, CIN: 1 (3rd) -- 1 point
Patrick Bailey, SF: 1 (3rd) -- 1 point